I know I'm hard on you. I know that. You can't hold it against me, though. I'm doing you a favor. You'll see. Don't show weakness; never cry, especially when other people can see you. Don't get into a fight, but if you do, win it. Keep your muscles strong, but don't worry too much about how fat you get; girls don't care about that anyway. You like girls, right, son? You'd better. You have to treat your woman right. Never raise a hand against her, even when you're drunk. But, don't let her run all over you. You're the head of the household. You make the rules, always. Always push yourself hard to provide for your family. Work hard, and don't complain. You'd better decide if you're gonna be a white collar pencil-pusher, or a blue collar kind of man. Either way can provide, but make your choice and stick with it. It's important to spend time with your buddies. A real man watches football every Sunday with the boys. You send your wife away when it's football time. Like I said, don't let her run things, but don't be a jerk to her either. You'll learn the balance one day.
What about art, or literature, or music?
Forget that. Forget all that. Your job is to be a man. You work hard and you expect some things in return. A hot plate of food and a warm bed isn't too much to ask for after a long day at work. You want to go stare at some paintings like some kinda wussy boy? Go do that shit in New York or something, and leave the hard country work to the real men. Son, men make sacrifices. We can't afford to be seen playin' the flute or somethin' like that. You wanna do that, might as well go be a cheerleader. Might as well be on the flag squad instead of the football team. You understand what I mean?
I think so. I'll do my best, Dad.
I know you will, son. And I'll always love you. Just don't disappoint me.
Thoughts:
This was a little more difficult for me to write than usual, for a couple of reasons. First off, the writing style is decidedly unusual. I didn't go quite as semicolon-crazy as Jamaica Kincaid did, but this exercise shares the terse, rough qualities of her work.
The other reason this was difficult was that it's uncomfortable to write things from a perspective I don't agree with. I have been lucky enough to have been born into an accepting, loving family. I was never pushed hard to be a "man's man". I know a lot of men who were, though, and they tell me stories of being borderline abused by their fathers if they stepped out of line (disobeyed an order, acted too feminine, etc.)
Obviously there are some elements of homophobia in what I've written. Again, this is purely from a perspective of what I could imagine a father in perhaps a rural, religious area of America might be like. Young men are pushed hard to act like men, to be brave and tough, and obviously anything other than perfect heterosexual behavior is strictly forbidden by the "Unwritten Code of Men", at least in certain families. These are not beliefs that I personally share, it's just what immediately sprung to mind when I thought of this sort of old-fashioned, tough-guy dad giving life lessons to his son might be.
Another aspect of this is the discouragement of pursing the arts. Young men are sometimes encouraged to just focus on the tangible, physical things in life, especially if they come from a long line of blue collar workers. They are born into this sort of clear delineation that tells them, "hey, even if you're smart enough to do advanced math or can paint beautiful pictures, your place is here in the shop working on engines. Your place is out on the field scoring touchdowns."
A final note is that I get a strong sense from
Girl that the mother is trying to relive her life vicariously through her daughter, and is pushing her to avoid making the same mistakes she did. The key difference here between legitimate advice and something that is harmful is that the mother isn't doing it out of the goodness of her heart; she's doing it because she wants to go back in time and correct her own mistakes, in a way.